A Florida nurse’s viral vow to deny anesthesia to “MAGA” patients ended the only way a functioning medical system can tolerate: with his license gone.
Quick Take
- Erik Martindale, described in reports as a Florida nurse/anesthesiology professional, was accused of posting that he would refuse anesthesia for “MAGA” supporters.
- The post was deleted after backlash, and Martindale claimed his social media accounts were hacked—an explanation reporters said could not be independently verified.
- Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier publicly urged the Florida Board of Nursing to revoke the license, arguing politics cannot dictate patient care.
- Martindale later voluntarily relinquished his nursing license “effective immediately,” ending his ability to practice under that credential.
What the viral post claimed—and what remains unverified
Erik Martindale, identified across coverage as a Florida registered nurse with anesthesia credentials and a University of Miami connection, was thrust into national attention after a Facebook post spread widely in late January 2026. The screenshotted message said he would not perform anesthesia for surgeries or procedures on “MAGA,” framing the refusal as his “right,” his “ethical oath,” and a business-owner prerogative. Multiple outlets reported the post’s authenticity could not be independently confirmed.
Martindale deleted the post as criticism accelerated, then stated his Facebook, Messenger, and Instagram accounts had been hacked. That claim, like the underlying screenshot itself, has not been conclusively proven in the reporting provided. What is clear is the public reaction: Americans—especially conservatives who already worry politics is creeping into institutions—saw a direct threat to the principle that emergency and surgical care cannot hinge on a voter preference.
Erik Martindale, a registered Florida nurse says he won’t give anesthesia for Republicans undergoing surgery and believes that’s his right and is ethical.
He needs to be fired and stripped of his license immediately. @FLNursingBoard pic.twitter.com/xzfu085DdE
— Scott Adams (@scottadamsshow) January 26, 2026
Florida’s attorney general steps in as regulators face pressure
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, a Republican, responded publicly as the story grew. Reports say he called on the Florida Board of Nursing to revoke Martindale’s license, signaling that a political refusal of care is incompatible with professional standards. The Board of Nursing is the entity that oversees licensing and discipline, but high-profile intervention from the attorney general functioned as a warning shot to the broader healthcare field that social-media activism can collide with licensure.
The speed of the escalation matters. The controversy was not treated as a private workplace dispute; it became a public question of whether state regulators will enforce non-discrimination norms when the targeted group is conservatives. Even with uncertainty about the original post’s provenance, the political damage was already done: the episode reinforced fears that some professionals see “MAGA” not as fellow citizens, but as people to be punished through essential services.
Why “refuse care” hits differently when anesthesia is involved
Anesthesia is not a symbolic service. It is integral to surgeries and procedures where delay or denial can raise serious safety risks, and patients have limited ability to “shop around” in the moment, especially in urgent contexts. That reality is why critics quoted in coverage compared a political refusal to other forms of discrimination and pointed to core healthcare ethics: treat patients without regard to personal feelings or ideology. The reporting frames the conduct as a bright-line issue.
Martindale’s defense, as presented in coverage, leaned on the language of rights and business autonomy. Conservatives generally support freedom of association in private enterprise, but medicine is a licensed profession with special duties to the public. The practical conservative concern is straightforward: if political identity becomes a gatekeeping tool in healthcare, the country edges toward a two-tier system where Americans must wonder whether a clinician’s ideology will affect their treatment.
The SB 1580 backdrop and the limits of “conscience” claims
Florida’s 2023 law SB 1580 has been widely debated because it allows certain refusals based on religious, moral, or ethical beliefs and restricts discipline in some circumstances. Some commentary around the Martindale case used that debate to argue the law “works both ways.” But the reporting also underscores a key distinction: targeting patients because they are “MAGA” is not the same as a narrow conscience objection, and state licensing boards still set standards for professional conduct.
The broader policy lesson is that laws written to protect conscience rights can become rhetorical cover for conduct regulators and the public still view as unacceptable—especially when the refusal appears rooted in raw political hostility. For conservative readers, that is a reminder that cultural power struggles do not stay in academia or corporate HR. They can show up where families are most vulnerable: hospitals, labor and delivery, and surgical suites.
License surrendered, but the bigger question remains
By late January 2026, reports said Martindale voluntarily relinquished his nursing license, effective immediately, meaning he is no longer permitted to practice under that license. Coverage did not confirm a completed disciplinary investigation after the surrender, leaving open how much was adjudicated versus preempted. The outcome still delivered a clear signal: when politics collides with patient care, Florida’s leadership is willing to push hard for accountability.
The unresolved piece is trust. Even if the post was not authored by Martindale, the episode spread because many Americans find it believable that contempt could translate into real-world discrimination. If regulators, hospital systems, and professional boards want to restore confidence, they will need consistent standards: no patient should fear being denied care because they supported Trump, voted Republican, or wear a hat someone else dislikes.
https://youtu.be/OQiYIxT1pVc?si=2cIQnrhN-A6dtV9X
Sources:
Nurses Refuses Treatment MAGA
Who is Erik Martindale? Florida nurse refuses to treat MAGA supporters, faces backlash and calls for suspension
Florida AG pages nursing board to revoke license of anesthesiologist who said he would not treat Republicans
Florida AG doubles down on Florida nurse social media behavior as Boca nurse claps back
NHS nurse reinstated trans patient
